This rule aims to establish the principles of the publication and screening process for the papers submitted to the Journal of Greco-Roman Studies (JGRS) published by the Korean Society of Greco-Roman Studies.
II. Editorial BoardAll the business relating to the publication and screening for JGRS is supervised by the editorial board.
III. Date of PublicationJGRS appears three times a year, on the last day of March, September and December. If necessary, a special issue can be published on the last day of June.
IV. Submission of papers
|
Evaluation results |
Verdict |
Reference |
||
Referee 1 |
Referee 2 |
Referee 3 |
|||
1 |
Acceptance |
Acceptance |
Acceptance |
Acceptance |
The author is recommended to correct the points that are commented by the referees. |
Acceptance |
Acceptance |
Acceptance with revision |
|||
Acceptance |
Acceptance with revision |
Acceptance with revision |
|||
2 |
Acceptance |
Acceptance |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
Acceptance with revision |
After checking revisions of the manuscript, the editorial board will decide if the paper is to be published. |
Acceptance |
Acceptance |
Rejection |
|||
Acceptance |
Acceptance with revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
|||
Acceptance with revision |
Acceptance with revision |
Acceptance with revision |
|||
Acceptance with revision |
Acceptance with revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
|||
3 |
Acceptance |
Acceptance with revision |
Rejection |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
The editor in chief designates a new referee after the editorial board decides re-evaluation. |
Acceptance |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
|||
Acceptance |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
Rejection |
|||
Acceptance |
Rejection |
Rejection |
|||
Acceptance with revision |
Acceptance with revision |
Rejection |
|||
Acceptance with revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
|||
Acceptance with revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
Rejection |
|||
4 |
Acceptance with revision |
Rejection |
Rejection |
Rejection |
It is decided that the submitted article is not to be published. |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
|||
To be re-evaluated after revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
Rejection |
|||
To be re-evaluated after revision |
Rejection |
Rejection |
|||
Rejection |
Rejection |
Rejection |
The editorial board ought to keep the papers published in JGRS in digital form (computer files).
X. Copyright of the published articleThe authors retain the copyright to their works, published in the Journal. However, the Society is permitted by the authors to copy, distribute, and transmit their articles (in the same format as published in the Journal) through information networks, such as internet with or without charge.
Supplementary Provisions
Attachment(1)
Evaluation Table(not open to a submitter)
Title of paper |
|
|||||
Evaluative items and grades |
A (best) |
B |
C |
D (worst) |
||
Purpose and Contribution |
How creative is the paper? |
|
|
|
|
|
Does the submitter attain the goal? |
|
|
|
|
||
How much does the submitter contribute to the field of related research? |
|
|
|
|
||
Argument and Composition |
How confidently are the materials used in this paper? |
|
|
|
|
|
How efficiently does the author treat relevant evidence? |
|
|
|
|
||
How logically is the paper composed? |
|
|
|
|
||
How properly are the references utilized in the paper? |
|
|
|
|
||
How systematic is the explanation? |
|
|
|
|
||
General Evaluation |
Acceptance |
Acceptance with revision |
To be re-evaluated after revision |
Rejection |
||
|
|
|
|